# `> open configury door`

# `> look`

`You are in a maze of twisty passages, all different.`

`It is dark. You are likely to be eaten by a Canadian cross build.`

## Notes on libstdc++-v3 configury

> No problem is insoluble in all conceivable circumstances.
> -- The Cosmic AC, The Last Question, by Isaac Asimov

- what comes from where
- storing information in non-AC files, like configure.host
- general config notes
- acinclude.m4 layout
- `--enable` howto

### what comes from where

Regenerate using a command sequence like `"aclocal-1.7 && autoconf2.50 && autoheader2.50 && automake-1.7"` as needed. And/or configure with --enable-maintainer-mode.

### storing information in non-AC files, like configure.host

Until that glorious day when we can use AC_TRY_LINK with a cross-compiler, we have to hardcode the results of what the tests would have shown if they could be run. So we have an inflexible mess like crossconfig.m4.

Wouldn't it be nice if we could store that information in files like configure.host, which can be modified without needing to regenerate anything, and can even be tweaked without really knowing how the configury all works? Perhaps break the pieces of crossconfig.m4 out and place them in their appropriate config/{cpu,os} directory.

Alas, writing macros like "`AC_DEFINE(HAVE_A_NICE_DAY)`" can only be done inside files which are passed through autoconf. Files which are pure shell script can be source'd at configure time. Files which contain autoconf macros must be processed with autoconf. We could still try breaking the pieces out into "config/*/cross.m4" bits, for instance, but then we would need arguments to aclocal/autoconf to properly find them all when generating configure. I would discourage that.

### general config notes

Lots of stuff got thrown out because the new autotools kindly generate the same (or better) shell code for us.

Most comments should use {octothorpes, shibboleths, hash marks, pound signs, whatevers} rather than "dnl". Nearly all comments in configure.ac should. Comments inside macros written in ancilliary .m4 files should. About the only comments which should not use #, but use dnl instead, are comments outside our own macros in the ancilliary files. The difference is that # comments show up in `configure` (which is most helpful for debugging), while dnl'd lines just vanish. Since the macros in ancilliary files generate code which appears in odd places, their "outside" comments tend to not be useful while reading `configure`.

Do not use any `$target*` variables, such as `$target_alias`. The single exception is in configure.ac, for automake+dejagnu's sake.

### acinclude.m4 layout

The nice thing about acinclude.m4/aclocal.m4 is that macros aren't actually performed/called/expanded/whatever here, just loaded. So we can arrange the contents however we like. As of this writing, acinclude.m4 is arranged as follows:

        GLIBCXX_CHECK_HOST
        GLIBCXX_TOPREL_CONFIGURE
        GLIBCXX_CONFIGURE

All the major variable "discovery" is done here. CXX, multilibs, etc.

        fragments included from elsewhere

Right now, "fragments" == "the math/linkage bits".

        GLIBCXX_CHECK_COMPILER_FEATURES
        GLIBCXX_CHECK_LINKER_FEATURES
        GLIBCXX_CHECK_WCHAR_T_SUPPORT

Next come extra compiler/linker feature tests. Wide character support was placed here because I couldn't think of another place for it. It will probably get broken apart like the math tests, because we're still disabling wchars on systems which could actually support them.

        GLIBCXX_CHECK_SETRLIMIT_ancilliary
        GLIBCXX_CHECK_SETRLIMIT
        GLIBCXX_CHECK_S_ISREG_OR_S_IFREG
        GLIBCXX_CHECK_POLL
        GLIBCXX_CHECK_WRITEV

        GLIBCXX_CONFIGURE_TESTSUITE

Feature tests which only get used in one place. Here, things used only in the testsuite, plus a couple bits used in the guts of I/O.

        GLIBCXX_EXPORT_INCLUDES
        GLIBCXX_EXPORT_FLAGS
        GLIBCXX_EXPORT_INSTALL_INFO

Installation variables, multilibs, working with the rest of the compiler. Many of the critical variables used in the makefiles are set here.

        GLIBGCC_ENABLE
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE_C99
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE_CHEADERS
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE_CLOCALE
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE_CONCEPT_CHECKS
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE_CSTDIO
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE_CXX_FLAGS
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE_C_MBCHAR
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE_DEBUG
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE_DEBUG_FLAGS
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE_LONG_LONG
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE_PCH
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE_SJLJ_EXCEPTIONS
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE_SYMVERS
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE_THREADS

All the features which can be controlled with enable/disable configure options. Note how they're alphabetized now? Keep them like that. :-)

        AC_LC_MESSAGES
        libtool bits

Things which we don't seem to use directly, but just has to be present otherwise stuff magically goes wonky.

### `--enable` howto

All the GLIBCXX_ENABLE_FOO macros use a common helper, GLIBCXX_ENABLE. (You don't have to use it, but it's easy.) The helper does two things for us:

1. Builds the call to the AC_ARG_ENABLE macro, with --help text properly quoted and aligned. (Death to changequote!)
2. Checks the result against a list of allowed possibilities, and signals a fatal error if there's no match. This means that the rest of the GLIBCXX_ENABLE_FOO macro doesn't need to test for strange arguments, nor do we need to protect against empty/whitespace strings with the `"x$foo" = "xbar"` idiom.

Doing these things correctly takes some extra autoconf/autom4te code, which made our macros nearly illegible. So all the ugliness is factored out into this one helper macro.

Many of the macros take an argument, passed from when they are expanded in configure.ac. The argument controls the default value of the enable/disable switch. Previously, the arguments themselves had defaults. Now they don't, because that's extra complexity with zero gain for us.

There are three "overloaded signatures". When reading the descriptions below, keep in mind that the brackets are autoconf's quotation characters, and that they will be stripped. Examples of just about everything occur in acinclude.m4, if you want to look.

        GLIBCXX_ENABLE (FEATURE, DEFAULT, HELP-ARG, HELP-STRING)
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE (FEATURE, DEFAULT, HELP-ARG, HELP-STRING, permit a|b|c)
        GLIBCXX_ENABLE (FEATURE, DEFAULT, HELP-ARG, HELP-STRING, SHELL-CODE-HANDLER)

- FEATURE is the string that follows --enable. The results of the test (such as it is) will be in the variable $enable_FEATURE, where FEATURE has been squashed. Example: `[extra-foo]`, controlled by the --enable-extra-foo option and stored in $enable_extra_foo.

- DEFAULT is the value to store in $enable_FEATURE if the user does not pass --enable/--disable. It should be one of the permitted values passed later. Examples: `[yes]`, or `[bar]`, or `[$1]` (which passes the argument given to the GLIBCXX_ENABLE_FOO macro as the default).

  For cases where we need to probe for particular models of things, it is useful to have an undocumented "auto" value here (see GLIBCXX_ENABLE_CLOCALE for an example).

- HELP-ARG is any text to append to the option string itself in the --help output. Examples: `[]` (i.e., an empty string, which appends nothing), `[=BAR]`, which produces `--enable-extra-foo=BAR`, and `[@<:@=BAR@:>@]`, which produces `--enable-extra-foo[=BAR]`. See the difference? See what it implies to the user?

  If you're wondering what that line noise in the last example was, that's how you embed autoconf special characters in output text. They're called quadrigraphs and you should use them whenever necessary.

- HELP-STRING is what you think it is. Do not include the "default" text like we used to do; it will be done for you by GLIBCXX_ENABLE. By convention, these are not full English sentences. Example: [turn on extra foo]

With no other arguments, only the standard autoconf patterns are allowed: "`--{enable,disable}-foo[={yes,no}]`" The $enable_FEATURE variable is guaranteed to equal either "yes" or "no" after the macro. If the user tries to pass something else, an explanatory error message will be given, and configure will halt.

The second signature takes a fifth argument, "`[permit a|b|c|...]`" This allows a or b or ... after the equals sign in the option, and $enable_FEATURE is guaranteed to equal one of them after the macro. Note that if you want to allow plain --enable/--disable with no "=whatever", you must include "yes" and "no" in the list of permitted values. Also note that whatever you passed as DEFAULT must be in the list. If the user tries to pass something not on the list, a semi-explanatory error message will be given, and configure will halt. Example: `[permit generic|gnu|ieee_1003.1-2001|yes|no|auto]`

The third signature takes a fifth argument. It is arbitrary shell code to execute if the user actually passes the enable/disable option. (If the user does not, the default is used. Duh.) No argument checking at all is done in this signature. See GLIBCXX_ENABLE_CXX_FLAGS for an example of handling, and an error message.